Is Metal Roofing a Good Choice for San Antonio Texas?
Short Answer: YES!
Metal roofing is a great option for San Antonio and the surrounding areas as the benefits of metal roofing generally seem to outweigh the drawbacks for many homeowners. This is because metal roofing straddles the line between reasonable cost and strength, with only some minor, aesthetic drawbacks.
In today’s world, there are dozens of different roofing materials, ranging from asphalt to wood to plastic composites. An option that has become more popular in recent years is metal roofing. Homeowners originally liked the idea of metal roofing for its durability. But as time has gone on, metal roofing has gained even more of a positive reputation.
Price of Metal Roofing in San Antonio
In most places you look, you might find “price” listed under the disadvantages of metal roofing. This is generally a misconception. Metal roofing tends to be cheaper than most heavy materials like wood, slate, or other kinds of tiles, it does run a bit more expensive than asphalt. When most websites talk about the expensiveness of metal shingles, they are almost always comparing it to asphalt shingles. Again, metal roofing is more expensive to install than asphalt roofing (sometimes, it can cost twice as much), but it is not more expensive than many other roofing options.
Longevity of Metal Roofing
Beyond this, homeowners should keep in mind that increased durability equates to lower long-term cost. That is, most metal roofing last more than twice as long as asphalt shingles. Metal roofing generally lasts 50 years and has a 50 year warranty to boot. Asphalt shingles should be replaced every twenty years or so. This means that, within the life span of a metal roof, asphalt roofing may need to be replaced twice or even three times. The cost of repairing and replacing an asphalt roof that many times over fifty years actually equals more money than the cost of installing a metal roof. So, even if the upfront cost of a metal roof is greater than the upfront cost of an asphalt roof, the long-term cost of a metal roof could actually be cheaper than the long-term cost of an asphalt roof.
Insulation Benefits of Metal Roofing
Additionally, metal roofing actually has insulation benefits, reflecting back certain solar heat. This keeps homes cooler, which is a big deal in a place like San Antonio! Various estimates say that a well-built metal roof can lower energy costs by as much as 40%. (https://www.decra.com/is-metal-roofing-energy-efficient). This is yet another way that the long-term costs of metal roofing can outweigh the long-term costs of other roofing materials.
Versatility of Metal Roofing
Metal roofing is unique in that it comes in a wide variety of forms, colors, and materials. Depending on the budget homeowners have for the project, they may choose to select hidden-fastener/standing seam roofing, exposed seam roofing, or stamped metal roofing. Hidden-fastener roofing is exactly what it sounds like; none of the fasteners that keep the roof in place are visible. More commonly called “standing-seam” roofing, this type of roofing is the most expensive because it requires experts with specific knowledge, like those at Bear Roofing, to install it. If you can find someone skilled enough to install this kind of roofing, Bear Roofing Company recommends it above other metal roofs, since its fasteners are hidden beneath the roof and won’t wear down in bad weather.
Exposed Fastening Roofs
Exposed fastening roofs are also what they sound like: a metal roof with some of the fasteners exposed. Most roofs with metal plating are of this sort. In many cases, as is the case with Bear Roofing, the roofers mold these panels to fit the roof onsite. They then fasten panels using special, seal-tight fasteners to ensure that no water seeps below the roof. This results in the classic homestyle, metal roof. One drawback to exposed fasteners is that the rubber seals that keep the roof from being damaged have to be replaced every seven years or so.
uPanel, rPanel and Corrugated
Exposed-fastener can be further broken down into uPanel, rPanel or corrugated. “uPanel roofing” and “rPanel roofing” describe the shape that the metal slats make. A good uPanel roofing slat will look just like a “u,” with a flat space in between each rib. Most rPanel roofing slats have a series of bigger ribs and smaller ridges, looking almost kind of like a ripple of metal. Whether or not those panels are “corrugated” refers to a kind of in-between style where the metal does not really have ridges, but rather has waves between the ribs.
Stamped Metal Roofing
Finally, stamped metal roofing is good for those who want the durability of a metal roof but the aesthetic of a different roof. As is the case with many plastic composite roofing materials, stamped metal roofing is molded to look like asphalt, terra cotta, or any variety of other styles. Depending on your values, stamped roofing, although more expensive than typical metal roofing, can bridge between your aesthetic sensibilities and your desire for a durable, long lasting roof.
Metal Roofing is Lighter than Asphalt Roofing
Metal roofing also has a unique characteristic in that it is much lighter than other roofing materials. This might not seem like an advantage, but consider this: certain roofing can only be installed on certain roofing angles. Slate, for example, can only be installed on super narrow-angled roofs due to the method of installation and the weight of the material. Whereas a house might need additional support to hold up a concrete, wood, or slate roof, if your house can carry an asphalt roof, it can almost certainly carry a metal one. A metal roof’s lack of weight makes it, perhaps, the most versatile roofing material out there.
Metal Roofs are Durable
It helps, then, that metal roofing is so durable. I’ve already mentioned how metal roofing can last more than twice as long as asphalt shingles. But it also protects against certain weather better than asphalt, too. Obviously, metal roofing doesn’t catch fire, not does it damage when struck by lightning. Even other adverse weather conditions — hail, high winds, etc. — are more prone to damage asphalt shingles than well-installed metal roofing. This combination of its light weight and durability continues to make metal roofing a popular choice among homeowners.
Metal Roofing is 100% Recyclable
Metal is also light in another way: metal roofing is light on the environment. Some sources say that America throws over 11 million tons of asphalt into landfills every year. Companies recycle very little asphalt waste because of the difficulty of doing it. Compare this with metal roofs, which tend to be formed out of recycled material. Additionally, metal roofing is 100% recyclable at the end of its life, since it can be melted down and made into something else. While this may not affect the performance of metal roofing, it’s still worth knowing that metal roofing does provide a massive, environmental impact without defaulting on its ability to protect your house.
Drawbacks · Mainly Aesthetic
The fact that metal roofing has a lower long-term cost than asphalt and is generally more durable than other roofing materials does not mean that metal roofing is perfect. As with any roofing material, metal roofing does have its disadvantages. Fortunately, most of these disadvantages tend to be aesthetic in nature, meaning that they won’t affect the structure of the roof so much as the roof’s beauty.
Color Matching Metal Roofing
One issue that homeowners have struggled with is color matching metal roofs upon repair or replacement. Simply put, if you need to replace your roof in fifty years, it may be quite difficult to find the exact same shade of color you used when you initially installed the roof. The market for roofing is always changing, and so do the colors of each roofing material.
Discoloration Can Happen with Metal Roofing
Another issues that homeowners sometimes report is a discoloration of metal roofing in certain climates. This is unlikely to happen in a relatively dry climate like San Antonio, but metal roofing generally does not mix well with coastal weather. Saltwater (and, in rare cases, water itself) can cause metal to darken, rust, or, in some cases, turn green. Most warranties that come with metal roofing, however, will specify whether or not the location of your house is viable for metal roofing.
Metal Roofs Can Dent if Hit by Heavy Hail or Debris
Finally, it’s worth noting that, while metal roofing does a fantastic job of protecting your roof from weather like hail, metal can dent. Some metal roofing companies advertise expensive metal roofs that do not dent. But most metal roofing will be prone to denting if hit by heavy hail or debris. This will not affect the roof’s structural integrity. Depending on the roof, though, it might look less appealing. Related to this is the complaint that rain and hail falling on metal roofs can be loud. Roofing companies install metal roofing with particular installation, so the sound of rain on a metal roof won’t affect those inside a house. But it can get quite loud for those outside!
Is Metal Roofing a Good Choice for Texas?
Metal roofing, although requiring specific expertise to install, is one of the most versatile roofing materials on the market. It fits on almost any roof, it has lower long-term costs than most roofing materials, and it is among the more durable roofing materials on the market. There are many other types of metal roofing styles to consider, too. Some homeowners might take issue with potential aesthetic issues, but an experienced roofing company with the expertise of how to install a metal roof can easily help you come to a decision as to whether or not a metal roof is right for your home.
Bear Roofing are Metal Roofing Experts
If, after reading our breakdown on metal roofs, you are interested in getting a quote on metal roofing, Bear Roofing can handle that! And, rest assured, we have all of the tools and experience necessary to install any kind of metal roof.